Thursday, January 17, 2008

Samuel Adams Irish Red

The new Samuel Adams Irish Red, a beer chosen by vote (between this style and a dunkelweizen -- rigged, I say, rigged!) as the next addition to the long line of Boston Beer Co's offerings. Smells fresh, malty, and a bit fruity, and a hint of caramel...unless that's anticipation of what I'm sure is in there. Mmmm...good body on this one, and yeah, there's caramel flavors. This is not an overly hoppy beer, but the earthy, spicy notes of East Kent Goldings are welcome. It really woke up my mouth with the piece of room temp Primadonna cheese I grabbed on a whim, too.

This is not for everyone. Irish reds are generally approachable beers, but this is perhaps too much for some. I say that because Cathy didn't care for it. I thought at first that it was the caramel malt, but after hearing what she said -- it's got that English taste I don't like -- now I'm not sure if it's the malts -- I think English malts are distinctive -- or the EKGs, which I just love. Cathy likes PNW hopping, crisp, piney, citrus, and this isn't that, not at all. She also likes malty beers, but usually more on the lager side. This Irish Red has a fuller body than most others I've had, and I like that, kind of a bridge towards Fuller's ESB in a weird way. The caramel might be overdone, but that's a defining characteristic, so that's like saying hops are overdone in an IPA, and, well, you can't say that in this country, right?

But this isn't Cathy's blog! I like this one, and encourage you to try it. Should be a good food beer with pork, chicken, and lighter fish; cheddar/Lancashire cheese, and nuts; pears, too, probably.

6 comments:

Travis said...

My wife says the same thing about English malt. She doesn't like some of the biscuit flavors. She especially dislikes anything with Marris Otter as the base malt.

Alan said...

What!?! There's no universal love of pale malt chewiness. That is the one thing that can attract me mose to a beer.

mhaugan said...

I agree about it being rigged. It is probably the easier beer to market of the 2 and they may have put their thumb on the scale.

Lew Bryson said...

Oh, I was just kidding about it being rigged. There are a lot more knee-jerk Irish-Americans out there than there are dunkelweizen lovers. But... I held a taste-off with the two beers at a party I had last August: a mess of brewers, wholesalers, beer-writers, bar-owners, and assorted high-end alpha beer geeks I know, and the dunkelweizen won hands down, something like 27 to 8 (there were also write-ins for barleywine and light, and one vote for "Jane"). We ain't exactly your normal crowd, though...

lamps said...

Well I was one of the testers and I chose the dunkelweizen - but hey, I liked the red also. Still have a test bottle in the fridge, think I'll try it tonight.

Steven said...

So what happens when you're a knee-jerk Irish-German-American? I guess you're (I'm) happy either way! ;-)

I'm looking forward to this brew after your report Lew. I'll have to try it next to Goose Island's Kilgubbin Irish Red -- the Goose beer leans a little more on the hops, should be a good tasting.